A “voracious appetite” for punishment
The failure of leadership on matters related to human rights and criminal justice lays at the feet of both Governor Scott and the legislature, Democratic and Republicans alike. Representatives at the Vermont Department of Corrections informed me that there is a “voracious appetite” from the Governor’s office and the Legislature to ‘lock people up.” Meanwhile, I’m hearing from people at facilities throughout Vermont who are forced to sleep three and four people in cells designed for two people. It should come as little surprise that the entire “correctional systems” in Vermont are broken.
It appears our Vermont communities have taken steps to either ignore criminal justice matters or revert to the tactics of “lock them up and throw away the key.” The Governor sits in Montpelier maneuvering and manipulating the state in to believing that we have a big problem with crime. We don’t. Vermont consistently ranks as one of the safest states in the country. And while Phil Scott espouses his “aw shucks” political theory, taking veiled jabs at the legislature, and not doing anything to attempt to resolve the issues, Vermont is facing a crisis.
According to information on the Department of Corrections website, in April 2020 there were 283 people detained pre-trial in Vermont prisons. In April 2024, that number rose to 445, and on April 2, 2025 that number was 505. We are going the wrong way. What, in the name of everything, is the legislature doing? Nothing. In truth, the House Judiciary and its leadership, in conjunction with the House Committee on Corrections and Institutions, sit on their hands.
Our small state holds the distinction of being the only New England State that uses the insidious practice of relying on the for-profit prison system. Congratulations to the legislature for failing to resolve the issue. With 36-plus pieces of legislation in the legislature attempting to tackle these issues (with multiple addressing the issue of use of private facilities), and only six having any movement, the legislature has taken exactly zero testimony from impacted families and populations.
There are legislators who are openly attacking people convicted of a criminal offense in our “brave little state.” These bloviating prognosticators in Montpelier have no knowledge of what it means to be involved and impacted by the broken criminal justice system, or what it is like to sleep on the concrete floor, with your head close to a toilet being used by three or more people. What it means to be separated by 1,428.5 miles (distance from Montpelier to Tallahatchie Mississippi, where Vermonters are held) from your family. It would be a good thing to hear from impacted people, families, and advocates.
April is “Second Chance Month,” a nationally recognized celebration of fresh starts and breaking barriers for people who have impacted by the legal systems. The elected officials in our little corner of the world can’t take the time to listen to those impacted, those sitting in our facilities with little or no support, those families without contact with their loved ones, and seemingly have no empathy for these voting citizens. Montpelier, from the freshman legislator to the leadership in both chambers, to the executive offices, have an obligation to represent all Vermonters.
Now what are you prepared to do?
— Tim Burgess, Executive Director, VT CURE
Currently there is a bill in the Vermont House, H.379, called the Second Look bill, that would create a path to potential sentence relief for those serving extreme sentences—15 years or longer. The text of the bill is here.
Tell your House Representative that you support H.379. Find your representative here.